451 CAOS Theory *
A blog for the enterprise open source community

Frustration and flight for my Linux netbook

, February 3, 2009 @ 2:37 am ET

I’m grateful to be writing a post about Linux netbooks that continues my rather bullish stance on the open source OS and the opportunity in this new form factor. You see, for a couple of recent days, it seemd I might have to retract some of my enthusiasm based on a disappointing experience.

I wrote recently about my hunt for a Linux-powered netbook, which was somewhat difficult to locate with several outlets sold out of Linux models while still offering Windows XP-based netbooks. I’m happy to report I was able to find a solid netbook running Linux and when it arrived at my home, it occurred to me that this was the first pre-installed Linux machine I had ever purchased (never mind the five other computers in the house converted from Windows to Linux or dual-boot).

I ended up going with the Acer Aspire One, and while I was somewhat reluctant about the pre-installed Linpus Lite after hearing that it was somewhat underpowered and somewhat limited, particularly for Linux, my wife and I figured we should at least try it out. While we found the Linpus useable out of the box, we went through some of the commands to broaden the options and applications available. Still, it was not on par with the experience I have had with the main distribution I use on my notebook computers: Ubuntu Linux in terms of look and feel, available applications and package management.

So before too long, I had created a USB key with Ubuntu Netbook Remix on it. I’m usually not one to get into beta software, but I figured it would be worth a try. After booting from the USB stick, the UNR looked nice from the get-go. The wireless connection was relatively easy to configure and before long, we were playing with this netbook version of Ubuntu. However, it, too, was somewhat limited in functionality and applications available. The next move was to switch to regular Ubuntu desktop (8.04 Hardy Heron, which is the basis for the UNR).

Since then, we’ve been enjoying our Linux netbook very much. We’ve tuned the desktop to the look and feel we each like using different user profiles, downloaded some of our favorite open source games and given the new computer a comprehensive test drive. I’m happy to report I still have confidence that Linux is a great fit for netbooks. I wonder if folks getting Windows XP-based netbooks will also be wanting to upgrade to a more modern OS? Time will tell.

Permalink | Technorati Links | Bookmark on del.icio.us | digg it
Comments (7) Categories: Software

7 Responses to “Frustration and flight for my Linux netbook”

  1. John Gill says:

    Funnily enough, I just went the same route as you. I went with the UNR remix after a day or two of Linpus. I’m wanting to get skype and realplayer (for BBC radio) on there, but not having any joy. Problem is getting binaries for the lpia architecture.

    I’m tempted to do like you and go to vanilla Ubuntu + then maybe just add the UNR repositories, but I am not sure that will solve the skype/realplayer issues.

    Other than that, loving the machine + with a 6-cell battery it goes for ages.

    • Nick says:

      You might want to try http://www.eeebuntu.org, as this is known to work on the aspire one, and gives you all the software you need out of the ISO. There are three types to pick from.

      Cod

    • Jay Lyman says:

      John, interesting to hear your similar experience. For what it’s worth, I’ve been pleased with the regular desktop version and everything seems to work fine. Gotta love that size and battery life, which should only get better.

      Also, thanks for the suggestion, Nick. Thanks for posting.

      JL

  2. stlouisubntu says:

    There is a special ubuntu customized just for the Aspire One
    based on Ubuntu 8.04.1 (or 2 I don’t recall) with the Netbook Remix
    and all hardware working ootb.
    Check it out at:

    http://www.linux4one.it/

  3. shamil says:

    UNR isn’t an official release, it’s not beta.

  4. [...] the Acer Aspire One with Linpus Lite left something to be desired. After having written about the latest Fedora, I was disappointed in the experience [...]

  5. [...] had four operating systems installed and run on it — it shipped with Windows XP, then it had Moblin OS onto USB and took that for a test drive, too. I’ve also used the Linpus OS that shipped on my [...]