Because 20+ data warehousing vendors is never enough

In our recent report on the data warehousing market we speculated that there would soon be a change in the number of vendors operating in what is a crowded market. We were anticipating that the number of vendors would go down, rather than up, but – in the short term at least – we have been proved wrong, as two new open source analytical databases emerged this week.

First came the formation of Dynamo Business Intelligence Corp, (aka Dynamo BI), a new commercially supported distribution, and sponsor, of LucidDB. Then came the launch of InfiniDB Community Edition, a new open source analytic database based on MySQL from Calpont.

We actually included Calpont in our report but its product plans at that time looked precarious to say the least as the company found that its plans to launch a data warehousing platform based on MySQL were overshadowed by Oracle’s acquisition of Sun.

We were somewhat sceptical about whether Calpont – which has had a couple of false starts in the past – would find a way to bring something to market and we are impressed that the company has reached a licensing agreement with Sun that supports its open source and commercial aims.

Specifically the company has arranged an OEM agreement with Sun for the MySQL Community Server version that enables it to be used with both Calpont’s open source and commercially licensed products. The first of those is InfiniDB Community Edition, a column-oriented, multi-threaded data warehouse platform which acts as a storage engine for MySQL.

The GPLv2 Community Edition will only be available for deployment on a single-server and without any formal support from Calpont and is primarily aimed at raising interest among MySQL developers. A fully certified and supported commercial version will follow, although Calpont is reticent about providing details on that at the moment other than that it will make use of Calpont’s massively parallel processing capabilities and modular architecture to scale out as well as up.

Calpont faces some competition in the MySQL segment from Kickfire and Infobright, particularly the latter given their similar open source software strategies (Kickfire is a MySQL appliance). Infobright has has grown rapidly since going open source and now boasts more than 100 customers, although Calpont maintains that leaves plenty of opportunities amongst MySQL users.

We would agree with that, and also with the company’s claim to offer something different from Infobright technologically. Infobright also offers column-based storage but not massively parallel processing (although it is working on a shared-everything, peer-to-peer architecture). We should note that InfiniDB Community Edition is also restricted to a single server but this is the result of a strategic decision, rather than a technical limitation. The commercial version will be fully MPP.

We recently noted that LucidDB is another open source database that is often overlooked since the LucidDB code is not commercially supported.

Any concern over the future of LucidDB following the demise of LucidEra should be put to bed by the formation of Dynamo BI with the intention to provide a commercially supported distribution of LucidDB.

As LucidDB project lead John Sichi wrote:

“This is an offering which has been completely missing up until now, and which I and others such as Julian Hyde believe to be essential for accelerating adoption of LucidDB. LucidEra provided much of the critical development effort, but never offered commercial support on LucidDB since that was not part of its software-as-a-service business model. Eigenbase provides community infrastructure and development coordination, but a commercial offering is not part of its non-profit charter. So in the past, when individuals and companies have asked me whom they should talk to in order to purchase support for LucidDB, I have never had a good answer. “

Meanwhile Nicholas Goodman revealed that the company has acquired the commercial rights to LucidDB and plans to offer DynamoDB as a prepackaged, assembled distribution. It will also be fully open source and all new features will be contributed to LucidDB.

It is very early days for Dynamo BI, which doesn’t even have a website as yet, so it’s difficult to judge the company’s plans, but with some of the lead LucidDB developers involved and a solid starting project – “the best database no one ever told you about” – it has every chance. We’ll be looking to catch up with the company just as soon as it gets up and running.

The data warehousing sector is extremely crowded and we continue to believe that there will be a shakeout in the near future, but there are opportunities for companies that are able to differentiate themselves from the pack. Starting a data warehousing company is generally not something that we would recommend right now, but both Calpont and Dynamo BI have opportunities to establish themselves.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


#1 451 CAOS Theory » Two new open source data warehousing launches on 10.28.09 at 6:33 am

[…] the rest of this post on our Too Much Information blog. Permalink | Technorati Links | Bookmark on | digg […]

#2 Nicholas Goodman on 10.28.09 at 10:42 am

The first public observation that our website is entirely lacking! 🙂

Matthew – you’ll find DynamoBI taking a decidedly different approach to the market and our customers. When we do get our website / product information posted you’ll see it reflects our views that:
– A great BI database is not JUST about speed and scale.
– Customers win when they get great open source code with stellar support.
– Services, build packaging, QA and support IS our product.
– We are huge sponsors of the community which we are part of (Eigenbase/LucidDB) but we don’t “own it.”

In short, we have every opportunity to actually deliver on the open source promise in the market. Our project has a long history, and has arrived to the market via dedicated, deliberate open source development by very talented DB Engineers over almost 10 years. While the company and support may be new, the project, code, and production use of the product is not.

I’d very much welcome sharing more – feel free to ping me via email left in comment.

#3 Matthew Aslett on 10.28.09 at 11:11 am

Hi Nick,

Thanks for the info. I agree there’s great opportunity there. Look forward to hearing more about it.

#4 Brian Moss on 10.28.09 at 11:56 am

Editing Note:
“demise of LucidEra should be out to bed by the formation of Dynamo BI” out s/b put


#5 Matthew Aslett on 10.28.09 at 3:22 pm

Thanks Brian

#6 Links 29/10/2009: Ubuntu 9.10 Released, Android Momentum Noted, 100,000,000 Downloads of 3.0 | Boycott Novell on 10.29.09 at 6:45 pm

[…] Because 20+ data warehousing vendors is never enough First came the formation of Dynamo Business Intelligence Corp, (aka Dynamo BI), a new commercially supported distribution, and sponsor, of LucidDB. Then came the launch of InfiniDB Community Edition, a new open source analytic database based on MySQL from Calpont. […]

#7 More From The Low End: DynamoDB is the New Lucid « Market Strategies for IT Suppliers on 10.30.09 at 6:54 pm

[…] the blogs I’ve provided links to; read them. You might also want to check out the estimable Matthew Aslett of the 451 group, who does the story justice along with another interesting development […]