Venture’s Vista

With Vista Equity Partners’ acquisition of a majority stake in Acquia, private equity (PE) firms are now on pace to deliver as many exits to VC funds as the previous record year. It’s appropriate (although maybe not surprising) to see a deal by Vista pushing PE purchases of startups toward a record streak – it has bought more of them than any of its peers.

According to 451 Researchs M&A KnowledgeBase, Acquia marks Vista’s 55th acquisition of a venture-funded company since the start of this decade. Only Cisco, Google and Microsoft have picked up more startups during the same time. And this year, Vista has been far more prolific, having printed nine such transactions, compared with six each from 2019’s next-most-prolific buyers of startups (Microsoft and VMware).

Last year, PE firms purchased 147 startups, 53% more than any other year, our data shows. With today’s announcement, sponsors are on pace to match that total, having bought 108 so far. In the overall tech M&A market, buyout shops are on pace to print 5% fewer deals than they did last year. The decline itself is hardly noteworthy – even if the year ended today, PE firms would have acquired more tech vendors in 2019 than they did in all but two other years.

But the growing ratio of VC-backed companies does show that the PE playbook continues to swing toward buying growth companies and adding value to them through bolt-on acquisitions. There’s every indication that Vista will run that playbook on Acquia. It’s a common strategy for Vista – of its 55 purchases of startups, 36 have been acquisitions done by its portfolio companies. Also Acquia, an open source content management software developer (subscribers to the M&A KnowledgeBase can see our estimate of Acquias revenue here), has recently become an acquirer in its own right, having inked two transactions since May.

Figure 1:

Cofense removes the Red Threat

by Brenon Daly


After a long and torturous process, email security startup Cofense has landed where it appeared headed pretty much the whole time: deeper in the portfolio of existing investor BlackRock. The private equity firm, which picked up roughly one-quarter of Cofense in a recap of the company in early 2018, added the 43% stake that had been held by a Russian investment firm. But it wasn’t an easy deal.

BlackRock’s transition from minority investor to majority owner of Cofense only came after some highly unusual – and highly disruptive – regulatory scrutiny from a secretive US national security agency. A few months after the deal was announced last year, the Washington DC-based Committee on Foreign Investment in the US (CFIUS) began pushing for the Russian investor, Pamplona Capital, to be removed from the syndicate. The reason? Perceived threats to national security.

Under scrutiny from CFIUS, business at Cofense stalled. Customers didn’t want to be buying from a potentially insecure security vendor. (Is the Kremlin reading your email?) Cofense’s growth rate, which had topped 40%, fell to about half that level, according to our understanding. The company had to do some layoffs due to the slowdown.

As growth tailed off, valuation followed suit. Although the exact price couldn’t be learned that BlackRock paid Pamplona for its stake, the transaction is understood to value Cofense at less than the $400m the two buyout shops paid for the company a year and a half ago. For comparison, rival email security provider KnowBe4 raised money this summer at a valuation of more than $1bn.

Still, with the removal of the Red Threat, Cofense at least has the opportunity to get back to business. And a fair amount of business is available. Our surveys of information security buyers and users continually show, broadly, that phishing and the related concern of user behavior is the top-ranked security ‘pain point’ facing organizations. That’s the good news for the company. The bad news: Cofense didn’t even make it into the top-five most-popular vendors for security awareness training, according to the 451 ResearchVoice of the Enterprise: Information Security, Workloads & Key Projects 2019.

Figure 1: Security awareness vendors

Blackstone bags big exit in tightening market

by Scott Denne

In selling Refinitiv to London Stock Exchange (LSE) Group for $14.1bn in stock, Blackstone Group has managed the largest-ever sale of a PE-backed tech company. The deal comes amid an overall decline in PE exits, particularly among the largest assets. Although the shifting PE exit environment isn’t a dramatic swing, it’s notable given the rise in PE acquisitions in recent years.

The transaction values Refinitiv, a financial markets data provider, at $27bn when factoring in its debt. That’s nearly $4bn less than where the company was valued when Blackstone and two co-investors spun it off of Thomson Reuters last year, paying $17bn for 55% of the business. That’s not to say Blackstone is losing money on the deal – it put in $3bn of its own cash and will get more than that in LSE equity. Moreover, it won’t begin selling any of those shares for at least two years after the close, so its ultimate exit is still a ways off.

Still, in announcing such an exit, Blackstone’s an outlier. According to 451 Research’s M&A KnowledgeBase, PE firms have sold 156 tech vendors since the start of the year, approximately the same rate of exits as 2017, but 22% lower than 2018 – a record year for PE exits. The decline is more significant among larger deals. Our data shows that buyout shops have divested just nine companies (including Refinitiv) for $1bn or more this year, on pace for the fewest such exits since 2014.

The buyer it found is as remarkable as the record price it fetched in the sale of Refinitiv. LSE hasn’t spent more than $1bn on a tech purchase since 2007. And more broadly, strategic acquirers have only bought six $1bn PE portfolio companies this year. In 2018, they provided 20 of the 31 PE exits valued above $1bn.

The slowdown in exits comes as sponsors have expanded their pace of $1bn-plus acquisitions of tech companies. According to the M&A KnowledgeBase, PE firms have inked at least 25 10-figure tech transactions in each of the past three full years, whereas they would typically print 10-15 such deals in each of the years from 2010 to 2016. Blackstone, due to a lockup agreement as part of today’s announcement, will have to wait at least five years before fully exiting its position. But if current exit trends hold, many of its peers could be awaiting 10-figure exits for just as long and with far less certainty.

Take-privates take a break

by Scott Denne

Repelled by rising stock prices, private equity (PE) firms are on pace to print the fewest take-privates of tech companies in five years. The deals that are getting done this year involve, more often than not, businesses that have fallen off their recent highs. Yet many are still commanding premium valuations.

According to 451 Researchs M&A KnowledgeBase, buyout shops have acquired 10 NYSE- or Nasdaq-traded vendors this year, setting the stage for the fewest such transactions since 2014, when they purchased just 12 (there are typically 20-25 such deals annually). The Nasdaq has risen 25% since the start of the year, although our data suggests that sponsors are reaching for targets that haven’t benefited from that by picking up companies whose share prices have fallen below their 52-week highs.

Take last week’s announcement that HGGC would purchase Monotype. The $820m transaction, at $19.85 per share, is almost 10% below the stock’s highpoint over the past year. It’s not alone. Per-share prices in seven in 10 of 2019’s take-privates landed below their 52-week high. An eighth vendor, Ultimate Software, edged out its high by less than 1% in its $11bn sale.

That’s not to say these companies are going cheap. Ultimate, for example, sold for 10x trailing revenue. And Monotype, despite the turbulence in its stock, was still able to fetch 3.4x. In fact, our data shows that the median valuation for these take-privates is running at 4.1x, its highest point in this decade. Although PE firms have increased what they’re willing to pay, stock prices might just be increasing faster.

PE, not just VC, joins the IPO parade

by Brenon Daly

The tech IPO parade continues, but with a twist. Rather than having its journey to Wall Street backed by truckloads of venture dollars, the first enterprise-focused company in the second half of 2019 to put in its S-1 is coming from a buyout portfolio. Dynatrace is a private equity-backed spinoff, not a VC-backed startup.

The planned offering by Dynatrace would be the latest move in a rather unconventional journey to the public market by the application performance monitoring (APM) vendor. Founded far from Silicon Valley, Dynatrace got its start in the sleepy Austrian town of Linz in 2005, taking in only $22m in funding before exiting to Compuware in July 2011 for $256m, or 10x invested capital.

Compuware itself was taken private by buyout firm Thoma Bravo three years later for $2.5bn, which, at the time, represented Thoma’s largest single transaction. Shortly after, Thoma spun off Dynatrace from its one-time parent and consolidated its new stand-alone APM holding (Dynatrace) with an existing one (Keynote Systems, which Thoma took private for $395m in June 2013).

After all that addition and subtraction, Dynatrace now looks to debut on Wall Street. That’s a trick that rival AppDynamics wasn’t able to pull off because Cisco Systems snapped the venture-backed company out of registration. Assuming Dynatrace does make it public, it would mark the first IPO in the fast-growing sector since New Relic went public in December 2014. (New Relic currently sports a $5bn+ market cap.)

But it certainly won’t be the last. Dynatrace’s sometime rival Datadog, which has raised $148m in venture backing, is thought to be eyeing an IPO of its own. (Subscribers to the Premium edition of the 451 Research M&A KnowledgeBase can see our full profile of Datadog, including our proprietary estimates for revenue for the past two years.) Meanwhile, subscribers to 451 Research’s Market Insight service can look for our full report on Dynatrace’s proposed offering on our site later today.

PE slows its roll

by Brenon Daly

Buyout shops aren’t buying like they have been. After seven consecutive years of increasing the number of tech acquisitions they announce annually, private equity (PE) firms are on pace for a slight decline in 2019. The slowdown comes as the formidable buyers also start to scale back their purchases, shopping much more in the midmarket than in the billion-dollar range.

As we noted in our full report on tech M&A in Q2, we recorded an uncharacteristic drop in the number of announced deals in the April-June period by buyout shops, which had been the sole ‘growth market’ in tech M&A recently. PE firms have doubled their number of tech transactions in the past five years, but in Q2, they posted a second consecutive year-over-year quarterly decline in deal volume, according to 451 Research’s M&A KnowledgeBase.

To be sure, we don’t want to overstate the slight decline in PE activity. Based on midyear projections, between direct investments and bolt-on acquisitions by portfolio companies, deal volume for financial acquirers looks likely to drop about 6% in 2019, compared with 2018. Buyout shops still account for about one of every three tech acquisitions, our data indicates.

Within that slight decline in the number of prints, however, is a much more significant shift in where they are looking. PE firms are moving down-market in 2019, no longer looking to bag elephants. (Our Q2 report examines this trend in much more detail, as well as compares acquisition activity by financial buyers with their strategic rivals.)

Assuming the first-half pace holds, buyout shops are on pace to ink one-third fewer billion-dollar deals in 2019 than they did in 2018. So far this year, the M&A KnowledgeBase has recorded just 11 purchases by financial acquirers valued at more than $1bn. That’s the fewest big prints for PE firms in the first half of any year since 2015, when PE held just a mid-teens percentage share of the tech M&A market, or merely half its current level.

PE’s UK holiday

by Scott Denne

Amid the uncertainty surrounding Brexit, private equity (PE) firms are slowing their activity in the UK for the first time in five years. With an October deadline on the horizon and little clarity about how the UK’s exit from the EU might proceed, buyout shops are scooping up fewer targets in that country than they did last year. Most of the decline, however, has occurred at the edges of the market.

According to 451 Research’s M&A KnowledgeBase, PE firms and their portfolio companies have bought just 45 UK-based tech targets in 2019, on pace for an 18% decline from last year’s total (122). That shift counters a years-long increase, as the number of sponsor acquisitions of UK-based vendors has previously risen each year since 2014. Questions about a target’s ability to hire or sell its wares abroad post-Brexit seem to be having the most impact on those buyers that don’t often purchase UK-based companies, and lowering the appetite for discounted targets.

The most frequent acquirers remain active. The PE firms that have bought the highest number of UK-based vendors this decade (TA Associates, Vista Equity, Inflexion and HgCapital) have all continued to purchase there this year. All but Inflexion have acquired more than one UK-based company in 2019. And the decline seems concentrated on deals with below-market valuations. The pace of UK-based vendors trading to buyout shops for more than 3x trailing revenue has risen, our data shows, while transactions where companies sell for less than 2x have declined.

PE firms paying SaaSy valuations

by Michael Hill

A years-long increase in SaaS acquisitions by private equity (PE) firms is flattening out. Yet sponsors are spending far more than in the past for those targets – typically paying more for SaaS vendors than strategic acquirers do – as businesses shift more of their budgets toward hosted software offerings.

According to 451 Research’s M&A KnowledgeBase, PE shops have bought roughly the same number of SaaS targets as this time last year, following several years of increasing the volume of those deals 25% or more each year. Despite that, sponsors have spent more than $20bn on SaaS acquisitions so far in 2019, compared with $24.7bn for the entirety of 2018. Much of the jump stems from Hellman & Friedman’s $11bn take-private of Ultimate Software. Still, even without that transaction, PE firms have spent nearly three times as much on SaaS purchases this year as they did during the same period last year.

And 2019’s larger deals are coming at a premium. So far, the median trailing revenue multiple for a SaaS target in a sale to a buyout shop or PE portfolio company stands at 4.9x, a turn higher than any full year this decade. Our data also shows that 2019 marks the first year that PE firms have paid higher multiples than strategic buyers, whose acquisitions of SaaS vendors carry a 4.5x median multiple this year.

The increase in valuations comes as businesses are pushing more of their IT budgets into SaaS. According to our most recent Voice of the Enterprise: Cloud, Hosting and Managed Services, Budgets & Outlook – Quarterly Advisory Report, 67% of respondents expect to increase their spending on SaaS this year. What’s more, 38% expect SaaS to be their largest area of spending growth among cloud and hosted services.

A change of guard in the infosec market

by Brenon Daly

After an uncharacteristic half-year absence from the top end of the information security (infosec) market, a private equity (PE) shop has now put up the largest print in the bustling sector so far this year. Insight Venture Partners built on an earlier investment in Recorded Future to take a controlling stake in the threat intelligence startup in a deal valued at $780m.

Other than that, however, most of this year’s activity has been coming from newly resurgent strategic acquirers. In fact, except for Insight’s reach for Recorded Future, strategic acquirers account for all of the 10 largest infosec transactions listed in 451 Research’s M&A KnowledgeBase so far in 2019.

Already this year, Palo Alto Networks has announced three acquisitions totaling a cool $1bn in aggregate spending, Sophos has doubled up on deals, and FireEye has shelled out a quarter-billion dollars in its largest single purchase in a half-decade. Other infosec M&A mainstays such as Symantec, Akamai and Proofpoint have also been heard from this year, with all of them inking $100m+ acquisitions.

The key to many of these corporate deals getting done is that buyers are paying up. That’s particularly true for Palo Alto, which has made a practice of paying hundreds of millions of dollars for startups that measure their revenue in the tens of millions of dollars. But FireEye and Symantec have also paid double-digit valuations this year.

As strategic acquirers stretch on valuation, they have been able to elbow PE buyers aside. According to the M&A KnowledgeBase, buyout firms are behind just one of every five infosec transactions so far in 2019, down from at least one of four deals in each of the previous three years. Further, our data indicates that PE shops’ slumping market share of only 21% in infosec M&A so far in 2019 is a full 10 percentage points lower than their share of the overall tech M&A market.

PE’s customer experience play

by Scott Denne

As budgets for customer relationship management (CRM) software hit a four-year high, private equity firms (PE) are pouring into the space, picking up new platforms and inking bolt-on deals. The number of acquisitions by sponsors is heading toward a record as customers spend more in the face of complex customer experience challenges, our data shows.

Across sales, marketing and customer service, businesses are grappling with finicky customers. In 451 Research’s VoCUL: Digital Transformation survey, 75% of respondents said they are dealing with rising expectations among customers in recent years and 78% said their customer experience processes have increased in complexity. As a result, they’re spending more on software. In a separate survey last summer, 15% of respondents said they would increase their spending on CRM software – the highest reading since August 2014.

Last year, PE shops and their portfolio companies bought a record 45 customer experience and CRM software vendors, spanning subcategories such as marketing automation, contact center and social media analytics. According to 451 Research’s M&A KnowledgeBase, those buyers are set to surpass that level with 24 so far in 2019. Many of the transactions are aimed at addressing a larger market through bolt-on deals. SugarCRM, for example, printed its second acquisition of the year with today’s purchase of marketing automation specialist SalesFusion. Prior to its sale to Accel-KKR last year, SugarCRM hadn’t bought a company since 2016, our records show. In another deal this week, Insight Venture Partners’ Campaign Monitor printed its third transaction of the year with the acquisition of Vuture.